Andy Johnson has tallied the most penalties in the Premier League in a season, with 11 penalties scored in 2004-05.

Interpreted as:

most penalties scored by a player in a season

	NAME	PK	G	SEASON	CLUB	Rating	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Andy Johnson A. Johnson	11	21	2004-05	Crystal Palace		37	3,304	37	0.57	3	24
2	Luka Milivojević L. Milivojević	10	12	2018-19	Crystal Palace		38	3,420	38	0.32	2	14	1	57	25	4	2,781	23	0
3	Frank Lampard F. Lampard	10	22	2009-10	Chelsea		36	3,220	36	0.61	14	36
4	Alan Shearer A. Shearer	10	34	1994-95	Rovers		42	3,772	42	0.81	13	47
5	Mohamed Salah M. Salah	9	29	2024-25	Liverpool	7.50	38	3,380	38	0.76	18	47	0	130	61	6	1,856	393	18
6	Cole Palmer C. Palmer	9	22	2023-24	Total	7.30	34	2,628	29	0.65	11	33	0	108	46	1	1,870	138	6
7	Bruno Fernandes B. Fernandes	9	18	2020-21	Man United		37	3,109	35	0.49	12	30	0	121	51	3	2,816	124	3
8	Steven Gerrard S. Gerrard	9	13	2013-14	Liverpool		34	2,898	33	0.38	10	23
9	Jamie Vardy J. Vardy	8	15	2020-21	Leicester		34	2,844	31	0.44	9	24	0	83	38	4	773	176	36
10	Ruud van Nistelrooy R. van Nistelrooy	8	25	2002-03	Man United		34	2,905	33	0.74	4	29
11	Erling Haaland E. Haaland	7	27	2023-24	Man City	7.25	31	2,558	29	0.87	5	32	0	121	59	2	699	195	6
12	Erling Haaland E. Haaland	7	36	2022-23	Man City	7.27	35	2,777	33	1.03	8	44	0	123	60	5	827	225	8
13	Jorginho	7	7	2020-21	Chelsea		28	2,014	23	0.25	1	8	0	14	9	0	2,046	17	0
14	Paul Pogba P. Pogba	7	13	2018-19	Man United		35	3,011	34	0.37	9	22	0	105	50	3	2,789	114	5
15	Luka Milivojević L. Milivojević	7	10	2017-18	Crystal Palace		36	3,081	35	0.28	1	11	1	42	17	1	2,198	25	1
16	James Milner J. Milner	7	7	2016-17	Liverpool		36	3,159	36	0.19	3	10	0	36	17	0	3,322	70	2
17	Charlie Adam C. Adam	7	12	2010-11	Blackpool		35	3,051	34	0.34	8	20
18	Alan Shearer A. Shearer	7	22	2003-04	Newcastle		37	3,312	37	0.59	4	26
19	Thierry Henry T. Henry	7	30	2003-04	Arsenal		37	3,330	37	0.81	6	36
20	Peter Beardsley P. Beardsley	7	21	1993-94	Newcastle		35	3,150	35	0.60	8	29
21	Justin Kluivert J. Kluivert	6	12	2024-25	Bournemouth	6.67	34	2,357	29	0.35	6	18	0	63	29	2	1,166	152	6
22	Bukayo Saka B. Saka	6	16	2023-24	Arsenal	7.24	35	2,936	35	0.46	9	25	0	107	37	3	2,126	290	8
23	Alexis Mac Allister A. Mac Allister	6	10	2022-23	Brighton	7.21	35	2,886	31	0.29	2	12	1	86	34	1	2,288	66	0
24	Ivan Toney I. Toney	6	20	2022-23	Brentford	6.69	33	2,955	33	0.61	4	24	2	94	42	4	1,325	166	27
25	Jorginho	6	6	2021-22	Chelsea	7.41	29	2,278	26	0.21	2	8	0	16	9	0	2,178	14	0