Between the 1900 and 1909 seasons, Jimmy Sheckard collected the most hits for the Brooklyn Superbas, with 839 hits.

	NAME	H	G	AB	R	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	PA	TB	XBH	SH	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	wRC	WRAA	wOBA	wRC+	BRAA
1	Jimmy Sheckard J. Sheckard	839	753	2,815	503	140	65	29	342	338	37	284	199	3,257	1,196	234	67	.298	.381	.425	.805	541	159.7	.384	133	138.4
2	Harry Lumley H. Lumley	725	722	2,632	297	109	66	38	305	201	8	388	110	2,938	1,080	213	97	.275	.329	.410	.739	395	103.3	.357	128	88.6
3	Willie Keeler W. Keeler	592	405	1,717	315	51	29	6	149	72	21	22	83	1,876	719	86	66	.345	.378	.419	.797	312	71.5	.379	127	65
4	Bill Dahlen B. Dahlen	524	540	1,995	294	75	37	8	289	228	22	163	108	2,271	697	120	26	.263	.345	.349	.694	302	17.4	.337	102	4
5	Tim Jordan T. Jordan	468	527	1,780	215	73	24	31	227	251	9	261	48	2,088	682	128	48	.263	.357	.383	.740	284	83.3	.365	135	76
6	John Hummel J. Hummel	461	534	1,873	185	47	32	12	152	127	7	206	60	2,072	608	91	65	.246	.296	.325	.621	203	3	.305	97	-5.6
7	Phil Lewis P. Lewis	429	508	1,775	146	33	13	4	130	95	3	107	55	1,940	500	50	67	.242	.281	.282	.563	157	-34	.277	79	-43.1
8	Whitey Alperman W. Alperman	387	450	1,632	134	60	36	7	141	30	39	183	27	1,758	540	103	57	.237	.268	.331	.599	157	-13.6	.292	89	-20.1
9	Emil Batch E. Batch	315	348	1,253	134	38	22	7	98	65	3	120	37	1,361	418	67	40	.251	.290	.334	.624	135	-3.1	.302	92	-11.9
10	Lew Ritter L. Ritter	315	462	1,437	129	33	17	1	120	96	6	180	55	1,580	385	51	41	.219	.271	.268	.539	119	-45.3	.264	69	-55.7
11	Billy Maloney B. Maloney	310	408	1,427	153	27	24	3	81	104	18	284	77	1,605	394	54	56	.217	.279	.276	.555	128	-27.7	.276	81	-32.5
12	Al Burch A. Burch	309	315	1,177	137	30	12	3	60	95	1	142	58	1,300	372	45	27	.263	.318	.316	.634	133	8.8	.313	102	3.1
13	John Dobbs J. Dobbs	305	335	1,237	156	52	13	4	125	107	8	70	49	1,390	395	69	38	.247	.311	.319	.630	149	-2.7	.306	90	-16.6
14	Joe Kelley J. Kelley	296	241	946	167	45	29	10	156	93	9	44	44	1,052	429	84	4	.313	.380	.453	.833	189	48.4	.391	128	41.5
15	Bill Bergen B. Bergen	286	540	1,715	64	22	10	1	97	39	0	231	15	1,819	331	33	65	.167	.185	.193	.378	39	-140.9	.185	23	-149.7
16	Tom Daly T. Daly	271	230	863	160	55	13	7	145	88	10	76	58	976	373	75	15	.314	.384	.432	.816	172	42.2	.387	127	36.1
17	Doc Gessler D. Gessler	270	288	959	108	44	13	5	96	88	31	136	51	1,096	355	62	18	.282	.361	.370	.731	153	36.2	.355	121	26.5
18	Doc Casey D. Casey	256	291	1,101	126	36	11	0	54	86	12	83	38	1,248	314	47	49	.233	.295	.285	.580	109	-13.4	.289	87	-17.2
19	Tom McCreery T. McCreery	239	243	906	109	24	20	7	120	81	4	106	34	1,004	324	51	13	.264	.327	.358	.685	127	4.2	.328	100	1.7
20	Cozy Dolan C. Dolan	232	207	845	105	27	8	1	83	50	7	79	31	916	278	36	14	.275	.320	.329	.649	104	-6.6	.314	95	-5.9
21	Duke Farrell D. Farrell	223	230	821	85	26	13	1	94	30	8	60	16	872	278	40	13	.272	.304	.339	.642	96	-15.3	.306	83	-18.3
22	Sammy Strang S. Strang	190	212	779	129	32	5	1	47	120	14	92	62	925	235	38	12	.244	.355	.302	.657	114	10.3	.326	99	0.2
23	Charlie Babb C. Babb	182	226	756	76	26	5	0	70	80	23	110	44	874	218	31	15	.241	.332	.288	.620	93	3.1	.308	98	-3
24	Tim Flood T. Flood	181	221	785	70	26	6	3	83	38	12	100	22	869	228	35	34	.231	.277	.290	.567	74	-28.5	.275	70	-31.5
25	Charlie Irwin C. Irwin	177	196	700	84	27	2	2	63	53	16	44	17	784	214	31	15	.253	.320	.306	.626	85	-10	.307	91	-9.6