Between the 1951 and 1961 seasons, Mickey Mantle collected the most hits for the Yankees, with 1,700 hits.

	NAME	H	G	AB	R	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Mickey Mantle M. Mantle	1,700	1,552	5,519	1,244	241	66	374	1,063	1,129	10	1,136	124	29	6,699	3,195	681	13	28	69	57	.308	.425	.579	1.004	1363	596.4	.439	173	591
2	Yogi Berra Y. Berra	1,513	1,484	5,371	840	217	28	265	996	549	38	302	20	18	6,003	2,581	510	7	38	43	102	.282	.350	.481	.831	887	198.7	.369	127	194.5
3	Gil McDougald G. McDougald	1,291	1,336	4,676	697	187	51	112	576	559	36	623	45	44	5,395	1,916	350	97	27	8	93	.276	.356	.410	.766	712	95.9	.349	114	92.7
4	Hank Bauer H. Bauer	1,102	1,171	4,018	658	188	47	134	530	413	27	498	43	28	4,515	1,786	369	38	19	10	67	.274	.344	.444	.789	616	99.2	.355	118	96.6
5	Bill Skowron B. Skowron	974	947	3,270	455	157	38	142	592	242	30	489	14	12	3,578	1,633	337	8	28	25	116	.298	.349	.499	.848	546	137.1	.371	130	131.3
6	Tony Kubek T. Kubek	744	697	2,687	350	130	20	33	246	131	10	253	18	16	2,901	1,013	183	56	17	15	42	.277	.311	.377	.688	298	-32.9	.306	90	-35.9
7	Elston Howard E. Howard	720	769	2,513	298	100	33	79	376	155	8	334	6	11	2,724	1,123	212	20	28	40	67	.287	.327	.447	.773	343	31.2	.336	108	27.2
8	Andy Carey A. Carey	567	688	2,130	288	82	28	47	259	200	21	267	23	20	2,407	846	157	34	22	17	54	.266	.332	.397	.729	278	2.4	.327	101	1.1
9	Bobby Richardson B. Richardson	558	632	2,111	235	64	17	6	144	110	2	94	23	25	2,272	674	87	36	13	13	36	.264	.300	.319	.619	185	-75.8	.278	72	-79
10	Joe Collins J. Collins	546	788	2,109	355	70	21	78	295	301	4	226	22	21	2,440	892	169	19	7	6	44	.259	.352	.423	.774	325	45.3	.354	115	44.4
11	Phil Rizzuto P. Rizzuto	516	669	2,033	302	81	20	9	170	265	18	155	52	15	2,423	664	110	105	2	1	35	.254	.345	.327	.671	254	-24.4	.319	92	-24
12	Gene Woodling G. Woodling	441	464	1,527	220	72	23	40	232	256	4	132	6	19	1,798	679	135	8	3		30	.289	.392	.445	.836	281	73.7	.386	134	74.9
13	Billy Martin B. Martin	440	493	1,681	210	69	18	29	180	109	20	175	19	20	1,849	632	116	29	10	1	48	.262	.313	.376	.689	191	-22.8	.314	89	-25.2
14	Irv Noren I. Noren	394	488	1,451	214	66	15	31	198	166	12	151	16	13	1,649	583	112	7	13	7	17	.272	.348	.402	.750	205	15.3	.343	109	17.2
15	Roger Maris R. Maris	300	297	1,089	230	34	11	100	253	164	10	132	2	2	1,276	656	145	1	12	4	22	.275	.372	.602	.974	245	97.8	.418	159	94.4
16	Hector Lopez H. Lopez	285	336	1,057	153	37	10	28	133	98	11	156	5	2	1,189	426	75	14	9	2	24	.270	.335	.403	.738	147	10.4	.331	106	8.2
17	Jerry Coleman J. Coleman	285	442	1,150	144	37	7	8	106	105	8	136	11	7	1,290	360	52	25	2	2	34	.248	.315	.313	.628	111	-37.1	.294	76	-38.3
18	Norm Siebern N. Siebern	274	308	1,002	158	37	9	29	129	126	3	196	9	10	1,148	416	75	9	8	5	13	.273	.354	.415	.769	152	21.3	.344	116	21.3
19	Clete Boyer C. Boyer	228	319	1,011	119	41	6	25	104	92	5	191	4	6	1,133	356	72	11	14	7	22	.226	.290	.352	.642	100	-30.9	.287	76	-33.5
20	Bob Cerv B. Cerv	203	365	755	111	35	12	26	118	92	7	128	5	4	858	340	73	2	2	2	20	.269	.353	.450	.803	122	24.2	.361	121	22.2
21	Enos Slaughter E. Slaughter	168	350	663	90	21	6	16	98	108	0	69	4	5	783	249	43	8	4	6	10	.253	.356	.376	.732	95	6.5	.333	107	6.3
22	Johnny Mize J. Mize	148	272	573	52	26	1	18	105	59	8	56	1	0	640	230	45	0			14	.258	.336	.401	.737	78	4	.342	105	3.7
23	Whitey Ford W. Ford	122	298	630	70	13	0	2	51	79	1	117	0	0	750	141	15	38	2	0	6	.194	.284	.224	.508	40	-46.9	.246	48	-47.4
24	Jerry Lumpe J. Lumpe	120	159	442	63	17	6	3	49	43	1	52	4	5	496	158	26	5	5	9	11	.271	.334	.357	.691	50	-6.3	.306	90	-6.4
25	Bobby Brown B. Brown	119	160	462	55	18	2	8	72	64	4	27	2	3	538	165	28	7	1		9	.258	.352	.357	.709	63	0.9	.336	100	0.5