Between the 1985 and 1989 seasons, Don Mattingly collected the most hits for the Yankees, with 1,012 hits.

	NAME	H	G	AB	R	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	1,012	764	3,128	490	213	9	137	574	252	8	173	7	6	3,442	1,654	359	3	51	69	76	.324	.370	.529	.899	576	184.4	.386	141	171.4
2	Rickey Henderson R. Henderson	663	596	2,302	513	119	16	78	255	406	11	281	326	57	2,735	1,048	213	2	14	5	36	.288	.395	.455	.850	447	135.2	.381	138	124.8
3	Dave Winfield D. Winfield	660	614	2,332	374	124	14	102	422	274	4	386	39	22	2,627	1,118	240	3	14	32	76	.283	.357	.479	.837	398	95.2	.365	127	85.4
4	Willie Randolph W. Randolph	503	514	1,842	290	80	7	19	191	316	11	152	50	16	2,215	654	106	26	20	6	60	.273	.379	.355	.734	289	33.5	.338	109	25.5
5	Mike Pagliarulo M. Pagliarulo	473	636	2,073	267	96	9	98	303	208	14	464	7	5	2,316	881	203	7	14	32	32	.228	.301	.425	.726	262	-3.6	.316	95	-12.3
6	Claudell Washington C. Washington	259	282	902	123	44	3	26	124	58	4	161	31	8	968	387	73	0	4	4	13	.287	.332	.429	.761	125	13.7	.337	108	9
7	Bob Meacham B. Meacham	221	336	960	135	43	4	6	85	104	16	196	41	19	1,117	290	53	31	6	1	16	.230	.314	.302	.616	99	-29.8	.285	75	-33.4
8	Steve Sax S. Sax	205	158	651	88	26	3	5	63	52	1	44	43	17	717	252	34	8	5	2	19	.315	.364	.387	.751	93	15.1	.341	115	12.1
9	Mike Easler M. Easler	195	211	657	77	32	2	18	99	63	1	119	4	2	730	285	52	2	7	13	21	.297	.356	.434	.790	99	13.1	.344	113	11.2
10	Gary Ward G. Ward	188	245	777	94	31	1	20	103	60	3	147	9	2	851	281	52	6	5	7	29	.242	.297	.362	.659	80	-21.1	.291	76	-24.7
11	Dan Pasqua D. Pasqua	187	275	746	103	27	2	42	112	103	5	215	2	2	860	344	71	3	3	10	12	.251	.344	.461	.805	122	20.1	.352	117	17.7
12	Ken Griffey K. Griffey	180	186	636	101	35	4	19	95	56	1	75	9	9	706	280	58	1	12	4	9	.283	.336	.440	.776	93	12.3	.341	112	10.5
13	Don Slaught D. Slaught	179	214	672	67	46	4	14	81	54	8	111	2	1	750	275	64	7	9	6	19	.266	.324	.409	.734	90	8.2	.327	105	4.1
14	Wayne Tolleson W. Tolleson	176	282	763	94	20	4	2	50	81	3	140	15	8	863	210	26	14	2	0	10	.231	.306	.275	.581	67	-34	.272	65	-37
15	Roberto Kelly R. Kelly	166	198	570	86	25	4	11	62	49	6	119	49	17	639	232	40	12	2	3	9	.291	.352	.407	.759	84	13.8	.343	115	10.9
16	Alvaro Espinoza A. Espinoza	142	149	506	51	23	1	0	41	14	1	60	3	3	547	167	24	23	3	1	14	.281	.300	.330	.630	48	-11.7	.285	78	-14
17	Ron Hassey R. Hassey	136	156	458	54	30	1	19	71	52	5	37	1	1	517	225	50	1	1	5	15	.297	.374	.491	.865	84	25.1	.381	138	23.7
18	Jack Clark J. Clark	120	150	496	81	14	0	27	93	113	2	141	3	2	616	215	41	0	5	6	14	.242	.381	.433	.815	93	26.1	.368	131	22
19	Joel Skinner J. Skinner	119	206	556	38	23	0	8	54	29	1	158	0	4	600	166	31	10	4	0	19	.214	.253	.299	.551	36	-33.1	.249	51	-35.9
20	Rafael Santana R. Santana	115	148	480	50	12	1	4	38	33	1	61	1	2	521	141	17	5	2	0	17	.240	.289	.294	.583	40	-17.2	.268	66	-20.7
21	Don Baylor D. Baylor	110	142	477	70	24	1	23	91	52	24	90	0	4	564	205	48	1	10	6	10	.231	.330	.430	.760	72	7.9	.335	109	6.4
22	Butch Wynegar B. Wynegar	109	163	503	46	19	1	12	61	94	0	64	0	0	601	166	32	1	3	4	20	.217	.338	.330	.668	64	-4.7	.309	91	-6.2
23	Jesse Barfield J. Barfield	106	129	441	71	19	1	18	56	82	2	122	5	3	529	181	38	1	3	6	8	.240	.360	.410	.770	72	14.4	.350	120	12.2
24	Mel Hall M. Hall	94	113	361	54	9	0	17	58	21	0	37	0	0	391	154	26	1	8	4	9	.260	.295	.427	.721	44	1.2	.317	99	-0.4
25	Steve Balboni S. Balboni	71	110	300	33	12	2	17	59	25	3	67	0	0	334	138	31	0	6	5	10	.237	.296	.460	.756	41	4.3	.330	107	2.8