Between the 1903 and 1909 seasons, Willie Keeler collected the most hits for the New York Highlanders, with 974 hits.

	NAME	H	G	AB	R	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	PA	TB	XBH	SH	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Willie Keeler W. Keeler	974	873	3,313	482	65	30	10	206	220	48	67	118	3,792	1,129	105	211	.294	.347	.341	.688	464	75.5	.335	108	35.8
2	Wid Conroy W. Conroy	750	796	3,005	356	111	59	12	266	198	16	306	184	3,300	1,015	182	81	.250	.299	.338	.637	346	8.7	.309	92	-26.1
3	Hal Chase H. Chase	690	628	2,439	326	90	25	10	292	82	12	233	134	2,609	860	125	76	.283	.310	.353	.662	285	28.6	.322	100	1.1
4	Jimmy Williams J. Williams	663	685	2,536	290	123	45	16	358	206	18	266	59	2,821	924	184	61	.261	.321	.364	.686	341	46.6	.332	106	17.1
5	Kid Elberfeld K. Elberfeld	647	667	2,412	330	89	28	4	257	182	81	94	117	2,743	804	121	68	.268	.340	.333	.674	326	45.3	.331	106	16.9
6	Frank LaPorte F. LaPorte	393	392	1,418	162	66	27	4	160	76	8	144	29	1,530	525	97	28	.277	.318	.370	.688	179	29.6	.335	108	13
7	Red Kleinow R. Kleinow	323	516	1,484	135	43	20	2	125	130	8	186	36	1,668	412	65	46	.218	.284	.278	.562	138	-26.7	.279	74	-44.4
8	Dave Fultz D. Fultz	257	305	1,056	127	42	8	2	99	88	13	97	90	1,199	321	52	42	.243	.309	.304	.613	122	-7.1	.300	86	-18.7
9	John Ganzel J. Ganzel	253	259	941	112	41	17	9	119	54	21	79	22	1,035	355	67	19	.269	.323	.377	.700	133	18.3	.334	106	7.4
10	George Moriarty G. Moriarty	249	292	982	98	35	13	0	93	53	9	110	58	1,075	310	48	31	.254	.298	.316	.614	103	-0.5	.301	89	-11.9
11	Patsy Dougherty P. Dougherty	248	234	922	139	24	16	9	55	47	9	88	28	989	331	49	11	.269	.311	.359	.670	115	12.2	.322	102	2.2
12	Danny Hoffman D. Hoffman	213	236	837	115	20	9	5	69	69	15	176	62	942	266	34	21	.254	.322	.318	.640	100	8	.318	98	-2.2
13	Charlie Hemphill C. Hemphill	194	215	686	85	17	10	0	54	91	3	66	52	797	231	27	17	.283	.369	.337	.706	100	25.2	.349	122	16.8
14	John Anderson J. Anderson	178	175	657	74	30	13	3	96	31	7	45	29	706	243	46	11	.271	.311	.370	.681	84	11.2	.325	105	3.5
15	Deacon McGuire D. McGuire	160	225	695	37	24	4	0	67	57	11	84	8	771	192	28	8	.230	.299	.276	.575	69	-10.2	.285	77	-18.5
16	Jack Chesbro J. Chesbro	147	270	730	51	25	10	4	53	10	1	185	3	752	204	39	11	.201	.213	.279	.493	42	-35.5	.235	45	-43.4
17	Joe Yeager J. Yeager	144	172	524	74	22	8	0	54	38	22	41	11	601	182	30	17	.275	.349	.347	.697	76	14	.342	113	8.2
18	Al Orth A. Orth	143	230	538	49	13	7	3	54	21	3	59	8	574	179	23	12	.266	.297	.333	.630	57	0.3	.306	91	-5.8
19	Clyde Engle C. Engle	137	135	492	66	20	5	3	71	47	5	55	18	563	176	28	19	.278	.347	.358	.705	70	15.1	.348	116	9.2
20	Neal Ball N. Ball	125	155	519	45	18	4	0	45	25	2	112	35	565	151	22	19	.241	.278	.291	.569	46	-6.8	.279	77	-12.7
21	Birdie Cree B. Cree	111	125	421	53	6	5	2	31	37	11	43	11	483	133	13	14	.264	.339	.316	.655	53	6.8	.327	104	1.8
22	Frank Delahanty F. Delahanty	111	138	459	49	13	10	2	53	27	4	38	20	507	150	25	17	.242	.290	.327	.617	49	-0.9	.301	87	-7
23	Ray Demmitt R. Demmitt	105	123	427	68	12	12	4	30	55	6	43	16	498	153	28	10	.246	.340	.358	.698	61	12.7	.346	115	7.5
24	Jimmy Austin J. Austin	101	136	437	37	11	5	1	39	32	1	61	30	500	125	17	30	.231	.285	.286	.571	41	-7.4	.283	75	-12.6
25	Harry Niles H. Niles	90	95	361	43	14	6	4	24	25	4	29	18	400	128	24	10	.249	.305	.355	.660	44	6.7	.323	106	2.5