Aaron Judge and Jorge Soler were tied for the most home runs in May 2023, with 12 homers.

	NAME	HR	MONTH	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS
1	Aaron Judge A. Judge	12	May 2023	21	76	23	26	5	0	25	20	0	25	1	0	97	67	17	0	1	3	2	.342	.474	.882	1.356
2	Jorge Soler J. Soler	12	May 2023	27	107	20	29	2	0	25	13	1	34	0	0	121	67	14	0	0	1	4	.271	.355	.626	.982
3	Pete Alonso P. Alonso	10	May 2023	29	105	19	23	2	1	21	15	4	21	1	0	124	57	13	0	0	0	3	.219	.339	.543	.882
4	Christopher Morel C. Morel	9	May 2023	19	71	17	21	3	0	16	4	0	29	1	1	75	51	12	0	0	0	1	.296	.333	.718	1.052
5	Marcell Ozuna M. Ozuna	9	May 2023	24	91	17	27	3	0	20	9	0	22	0	0	100	57	12	0	0	1	1	.297	.360	.626	.986
6	Salvador Perez S. Perez	9	May 2023	24	96	18	29	5	0	19	5	1	25	0	0	104	61	14	0	2	3	1	.302	.337	.635	.972
7	Mookie Betts M. Betts	9	May 2023	27	108	26	29	6	1	22	17	0	18	1	0	126	64	16	0	1	0	2	.269	.365	.593	.958
8	Matt Olson M. Olson	9	May 2023	29	107	24	23	4	0	17	21	1	32	1	0	130	54	13	0	1	2	2	.215	.346	.505	.851
9	J.D. Martinez	8	May 2023	18	74	12	23	5	0	24	4	0	22	0	0	80	52	13	0	2	0	1	.311	.338	.703	1.040
10	Shohei Ohtani S. Ohtani	8	May 2023	27	103	15	25	4	1	20	13	1	28	2	0	117	55	13	0	0	1	2	.243	.333	.534	.867
11	Jose Siri J. Siri	8	May 2023	22	71	16	18	1	1	13	7	0	23	4	0	80	45	10	1	1	0	0	.254	.316	.634	.950
12	Christian Walker C. Walker	8	May 2023	26	97	21	23	4	0	16	13	0	23	0	0	110	51	12	0	0	1	1	.237	.327	.526	.853
13	Lourdes Gurriel Jr. L. Gurriel Jr.	8	May 2023	24	91	18	32	7	1	18	9	1	15	0	0	101	65	16	0	0	0	5	.352	.416	.714	1.130
14	Luis Robert Jr. L. Robert Jr.	8	May 2023	27	100	23	31	9	0	17	7	3	30	1	1	110	64	17	0	0	3	2	.310	.373	.640	1.013
15	Lane Thomas L. Thomas	8	May 2023	29	119	22	36	7	1	16	8	1	32	2	0	128	69	16	0	0	0	0	.303	.352	.580	.931
16	Yordan Alvarez Y. Alvarez	8	May 2023	27	95	21	28	8	0	21	15	3	22	0	0	114	60	16	0	1	1	4	.295	.404	.632	1.035
17	Nolan Gorman N. Gorman	7	May 2023	25	83	15	23	5	0	19	11	1	23	2	0	96	49	12	0	1	0	0	.277	.365	.590	.955
18	Nolan Arenado N. Arenado	7	May 2023	26	100	15	29	4	1	22	9	0	21	1	1	111	56	12	0	2	1	5	.290	.342	.560	.902
19	Anthony Santander A. Santander	7	May 2023	27	101	18	34	7	1	22	13	2	25	1	0	116	64	15	0	0	0	2	.337	.422	.634	1.056
20	Michael Conforto M. Conforto	7	May 2023	26	90	17	26	2	0	18	11	2	20	1	0	105	49	9	0	2	0	3	.289	.371	.544	.916
21	Kyle Schwarber K. Schwarber	7	May 2023	26	87	11	10	1	0	15	22	1	34	0	0	110	32	8	0	0	2	1	.115	.300	.368	.668
22	Ronald Acuña Jr. R. Acuña Jr.	7	May 2023	29	114	25	34	7	1	17	13	1	16	10	2	129	64	15	0	1	1	2	.298	.372	.561	.933
23	Fernando Tatis Jr. F. Tatis Jr.	7	May 2023	26	109	16	25	3	0	13	9	0	24	5	0	119	49	10	0	1	0	3	.229	.286	.450	.735
24	Francisco Alvarez F. Alvarez	7	May 2023	22	72	11	21	6	0	17	6	2	15	0	0	80	48	13	0	0	0	3	.292	.363	.667	1.029
25	Josh Lowe J. Lowe	6	May 2023	26	85	11	23	5	0	19	5	0	22	8	2	90	46	11	0	0	0	1	.271	.311	.541	.852