The Cincinnati Outlaw Reds had the best record by a team with 40+ games played, with a record of 69-36.

Interpreted as:

team with best record through 40 or more games

	TEAM	REC	G	W%	W	L	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS
1	Outlaw Reds	69-36	105	.657	69	36	3,786	703	1,027	118	63	26		147		482			3,933	1,349	207					.271		.356
2	Reds	174-90	269	.659	174	90	9,515	2,020	2,647	386	176	106	1,548	1,303	109	499	859		10,927	3,703	668					.278	.371	.389	.761
3	Browns	781-432	1,233	.644	781	432	43,777	7,933	11,555	1,658	602	304	4,657	3,473	353	436	2,307		47,743	15,329	2,564					.264	.325	.350	.675
4	Dark Blues	78-48	129	.619	78	48	5,022	770	1,348	159	53	6		69					5,091	1,631	218					.268		.325
5	Grays	438-278	725	.612	438	278	26,572	4,037	6,764	1,084	341	98	292	1,192					27,764	8,824	1,523					.255		.332
6	Brown Stockings	73-51	124	.589	73	51	4,656	670	1,173	124	63	3		116					4,772	1,432	190					.252		.308
7	Orioles	730-530	1,294	.579	730	530	45,361	8,530	13,521	1,814	865	218	6,940	4,345	992	2,952	2,993		51,317	17,719	2,897	619				.298	.372	.391	.763
8	Ward's Wonders	76-56	133	.576	76	56	4,887	964	1,352	186	93	34	748	502	42	369	272		5,431	1,826	313					.277	.349	.374	.723
9	Yankees	10812-8168	19,068	.570	10,812	8,168	649,886	92,671	172,534	28,650	5,497	17,329	86,109	68,619	4,930	94,894	11,655	2,802	736,319	264,165	51,476	9,595	3,289	2,836	10,687	.265	.339	.406	.745
10	Whales	173-133	312	.565	173	133	10,231	1,262	2,634	412	127	102	1,102	964	71	1,200	332		11,614	3,606	641	348				.257	.326	.352	.678
11	Giants	74-57	132	.565	74	57	4,913	1,018	1,393	204	97	66	793	486	31	364	231		5,430	1,989	367					.284	.352	.405	.757
12	Peppers	168-137	312	.551	168	137	10,273	1,347	2,757	440	170	50	1,116	908	72	1,160	457		11,678	3,687	660	425				.268	.332	.359	.691
13	Monumentals	58-47	106	.552	58	47	3,883	662	952	150	26	17		144		652			4,027	1,205	193					.245		.310
14	Pirates	75-62	138	.547	75	62	4,968	886	1,311	200	95	31	705	492	43	410	276		5,503	1,794	326					.264	.335	.361	.697
15	Giants	11572-10043	21,778	.535	11,572	10,043	743,245	100,690	195,483	31,356	7,038	15,592	90,162	68,325	5,678	99,636	16,517	3,146	831,929	287,691	53,986	11,666	3,015	4,018	10,189	.263	.329	.387	.716
16	Dodgers	11466-10089	21,694	.532	11,466	10,089	739,194	97,954	193,135	31,066	7,006	14,142	88,173	68,936	5,153	100,413	17,347	3,552	829,196	280,639	52,214	12,774	3,063	3,737	9,951	.261	.327	.380	.707
17	Athletics	633-564	1,219	.529	633	564	43,556	7,481	11,208	1,782	741	284	4,168	3,158	351	548	1,900		47,191	15,324	2,807					.257	.315	.352	.666
18	Reds	58-51	111	.532	58	51	3,940	636	928	168	32	19		128		787			4,068	1,217	219					.236		.309
19	Athletics	68-63	132	.519	68	63	4,855	941	1,350	187	113	49	761	431	51	321	203		5,337	1,910	349					.278	.343	.393	.737
20	Red Sox	9982-9293	19,358	.518	9,982	9,293	662,539	90,402	176,786	33,136	5,600	14,612	83,836	66,836	4,807	95,634	9,638	2,552	748,118	264,958	53,348	10,596	3,340	2,998	11,552	.267	.337	.400	.737
21	Grays	65-61	130	.516	65	61	4,925	619	1,300	143	50	15		82					5,007	1,588	208					.264		.322
22	Maumees	68-64	134	.515	68	64	4,575	739	1,152	152	108	24	512	486	71		421		5,132	1,592	284					.252	.333	.348	.681
23	Cardinals	10536-9994	20,661	.513	10,536	9,994	706,723	92,447	187,808	31,840	7,052	12,866	84,507	64,206	5,205	98,208	15,018	3,616	791,252	272,350	51,758	11,974	3,144	3,776	10,140	.266	.330	.385	.715
24	Cubs	11361-10788	22,310	.513	11,361	10,788	763,502	102,748	199,965	33,770	7,360	15,262	88,333	68,598	5,285	105,110	15,803	3,072	853,323	294,241	56,392	13,027	2,911	3,522	9,964	.262	.326	.385	.711
25	Guardians	9881-9394	19,366	.513	9,881	9,394	660,051	87,549	174,722	31,159	5,499	13,923	80,913	62,643	4,838	94,662	11,914	3,390	742,354	258,648	50,581	11,464	3,358	2,545	10,529	.265	.331	.392	.723