4 players are tied for the most career MVP awards for the Yankees, with 3. The first three are Aaron Judge, Mickey Mantle and Yogi Berra.

	NAME	MVP	G	AB	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	OPS	wRC	WRAA	wOBA	wRC+	BRAA
1	Aaron Judge A. Judge	3	1,145	4,105	873	1,205	203	7	368	830	817	40	1,369	65	21	4,995	2,526	578	0	33	104	116	.294	.413	.615	1.028	1050	453.4	.425	178	457.2
2	Mickey Mantle M. Mantle	3	2,401	8,102	1,676	2,415	344	72	536	1,509	1,733	13	1,710	153	38	9,909	4,511	952	14	47	126	113	.298	.421	.557	.977	1941	840	.428	170	821.8
3	Yogi Berra Y. Berra	3	2,116	7,546	1,174	2,148	321	49	358	1,430	704	52	411	30	19	8,355	3,641	728	9	44	49	146	.285	.348	.483	.830	1232	266.3	.370	124	246.6
4	Joe DiMaggio J. DiMaggio	3	1,736	6,821	1,390	2,214	389	131	361	1,537	790	46	369	30	0	7,671	3,948	881	14			130	.325	.398	.579	.977	1517	604.1	.439	152	528.8
5	Alex Rodriguez A. Rodriguez	2	1,509	5,577	1,012	1,580	263	9	351	1,096	779	104	1,292	152	30	6,520	2,914	623	0	60	60	151	.283	.378	.523	.900	1105	329.6	.385	138	303.2
6	Roger Maris R. Maris	2	850	3,007	520	797	110	17	203	547	413	27	417	7	2	3,475	1,550	330	5	23	23	50	.265	.356	.515	.872	567	179.9	.381	139	165.3
7	Don Mattingly D. Mattingly	1	1,785	7,003	1,007	2,153	442	20	222	1,099	588	21	444	14	9	7,721	3,301	684	13	96	136	191	.307	.358	.471	.830	1133	246.8	.361	124	221.6
8	Thurman Munson T. Munson	1	1,423	5,344	696	1,558	229	32	113	701	438	42	571	48	50	5,903	2,190	374	21	58	59	160	.292	.346	.410	.756	745	103.8	.340	116	106.4
9	Elston Howard E. Howard	1	1,492	5,044	588	1,405	211	50	161	733	342	24	717	8	13	5,485	2,199	422	26	49	72	148	.279	.324	.436	.760	683	74.6	.332	108	56.7
10	Phil Rizzuto P. Rizzuto	1	1,661	5,816	877	1,588	239	62	38	563	651	49	398	149	15	6,711	2,065	339	193	2	1	107	.273	.351	.355	.706	773	0.8	.335	96	-31.1
11	Joe Gordon J. Gordon	1	1,000	3,686	596	1,000	186	38	153	617	481	19	508	68		4,216	1,721	377	30			97	.271	.358	.467	.825	635	153.4	.381	121	109.9
12	Spud Chandler S. Chandler	1	211	548	53	110	18	2	9	45	20	4	154	0		605	159	29	33			9	.201	.234	.290	.524	28	-39.7	.247	42	-45.4
13	Lou Gehrig L. Gehrig	1	2,164	8,001	1,888	2,721	534	163	493	1,995	1,508	45	790	102		9,660	5,060	1,190	106			2	.340	.447	.632	1.080	2265	1,046.8	.477	173	980