Between the 1981 and 1984 seasons, Gene Tenace had the highest OPS by a catcher with >24 at-bats, with an OPS of .877.

	NAME	OPS	AB	G	R	H	2B	3B	HR	RBI	BB	HBP	SO	SB	CS	PA	TB	XBH	SH	SF	IBB	GIDP	AVG	OBP	SLG	WRC	WRAA	WOBA	WRC+	BRAA
1	Gene Tenace G. Tenace	.877	253	124	44	62	16	0	12	40	74	8	57	1	1	339	114	28	1	3	3	2	.245	.426	.451	58	21.4	.400	154	20.2
2	Gary Carter G. Carter	.827	2,068	558	277	578	121	7	89	350	228	20	213	6	13	2,350	980	217	9	25	31	44	.279	.353	.474	346	84.5	.364	132	84.2
3	John Wockenfuss J. Wockenfuss	.809	438	162	60	124	17	1	17	76	60	0	58	1	1	502	194	35	0	4	3	8	.283	.367	.443	73	16.8	.362	125	14.7
4	Lance Parrish L. Parrish	.779	2,017	531	269	523	95	9	102	345	159	4	377	8	13	2,205	942	206	3	22	24	54	.259	.312	.467	285	39.8	.341	112	32.1
5	Carlton Fisk C. Fisk	.778	1,661	471	249	440	75	8	68	239	156	29	245	35	10	1,870	735	151	8	16	17	36	.265	.336	.443	248	40.8	.346	114	29.3
6	Dave Valle D. Valle	.766	27	13	4	8	1	0	1	4	1	0	5	0	0	28	12	2	0	0	0	0	.296	.321	.444	4	0.5	.342	110	0.3
7	Bob Brenly B. Brenly	.765	1,012	333	141	276	46	4	32	133	109	7	130	22	19	1,144	426	82	6	10	13	29	.273	.344	.421	148	19.9	.341	117	21.8
8	Jerry Grote J. Grote	.764	58	24	4	17	3	1	1	9	3	1	3	1	0	64	25	5	1	1	0	2	.293	.333	.431	8	1.5	.345	119	1.3
9	Charlie Moore C. Moore	.761	156	48	16	47	8	3	1	9	12	0	13	1	4	171	64	12	3	0	0	4	.301	.351	.410	22	4.3	.348	126	4.8
10	Tony Pena T. Pena	.757	1,795	502	197	529	86	10	43	228	92	9	232	21	22	1,918	764	139	15	7	18	48	.295	.331	.426	240	26.5	.336	109	19.8
11	Dave Schmidt D. Schmidt	.752	42	15	6	10	1	0	2	3	7	0	17	0	0	49	17	3	0	0	0	1	.238	.347	.405	6	1.3	.350	118	0.9
12	Rich Gedman R. Gedman	.751	1,147	368	127	312	74	7	35	142	63	5	177	0	2	1,233	505	116	10	8	17	31	.272	.311	.440	148	11.2	.329	99	-1.1
13	Darrell Porter D. Porter	.749	1,412	453	181	339	68	13	44	213	233	12	271	8	9	1,674	565	125	2	15	37	29	.240	.349	.400	207	20.3	.334	110	18.1
14	Jody Davis J. Davis	.746	1,631	487	166	427	81	7	59	251	137	5	312	5	10	1,802	699	147	8	21	27	48	.262	.317	.429	214	12.9	.327	99	-2.3
15	Ted Simmons T. Simmons	.745	1,519	390	194	412	81	6	50	266	96	7	123	4	3	1,644	655	137	2	20	13	53	.271	.314	.431	197	15.1	.329	108	16.8
16	Ernie Whitt E. Whitt	.745	1,138	426	132	283	50	5	44	160	139	1	168	9	7	1,302	475	99	9	15	20	23	.249	.327	.417	156	11.6	.329	99	-1.2
17	Tom Nieto T. Nieto	.742	86	33	7	24	4	0	3	12	5	0	18	0	0	93	37	7	0	2	2	3	.279	.312	.430	11	0.2	.320	102	0.2
18	Terry Kennedy T. Kennedy	.741	2,023	551	208	564	109	5	54	293	132	11	332	3	7	2,198	845	168	8	24	38	40	.279	.323	.418	257	12.9	.325	107	17.9
19	Bo Diaz B. Diaz	.740	1,253	370	148	335	69	1	41	196	92	6	180	6	12	1,370	529	111	7	12	11	41	.267	.318	.422	163	10.5	.328	105	6.8
20	Butch Wynegar B. Wynegar	.730	1,170	357	135	318	48	4	16	125	184	3	106	2	7	1,379	422	68	13	9	11	41	.272	.370	.361	173	19	.335	109	15.2
21	George Bjorkman G. Bjorkman	.730	75	29	8	17	4	0	2	14	16	1	29	0	0	93	27	6	1	0	4	1	.227	.370	.360	11	0.4	.325	108	0.9
22	Dave Engle D. Engle	.729	765	229	102	218	42	5	12	81	54	1	61	2	2	832	306	59	2	10	4	31	.285	.329	.400	98	4.3	.325	95	-4.6
23	Ozzie Virgil O. Virgil	.729	703	251	83	173	34	2	27	99	63	8	153	1	4	780	292	63	1	5	5	30	.246	.313	.415	92	4.4	.325	104	3.2
24	Geno Petralli G. Petralli	.728	51	25	3	16	2	0	0	1	5	0	7	0	0	57	18	2	1	0	0	1	.314	.375	.353	7	0.8	.335	102	0.1
25	Chris Bando C. Bando	.728	572	210	69	144	23	1	19	78	74	0	86	1	3	661	226	43	6	9	6	20	.252	.333	.395	78	4.6	.326	100	0.1