Answered January 10th, 2020

Paul Hornung is the oldest in a game with 5+ touchdowns. He was 29 years and 354 days old versus the Baltimore Colts on December 12, 1965.

who is the oldest player to score five touchdowns in a game
Interpreted as:
Who is the oldest player to score five or more touchdowns in a regular-season game?

See Trending NFL Searches