Mike Bossy has scored the most career goals for the Islanders, with 573 scored.

	NAME	G	GP	A	P	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Mike Bossy M. Bossy	573	752	553	1,126	+380	210	180	198	8	1	80	4	2,709	21.2
2	Bryan Trottier B. Trottier	500	1,123	853	1,353	+467	798	158	257	17	18	69	1	2,626	19.0
3	Rod Gilbert R. Gilbert	406	1,065	615	1,021	+38	510	108	215	0	0	52		3,142	12.9
4	Jean Ratelle J. Ratelle	336	861	481	817	+108	192	82	141	2	0	46		2,045	16.4
5	Chris Kreider C. Kreider	314	840	249	563	+125	567	114	63	11	3	48	3	2,078	15.1	316	738	42.8	1,547	345	261	451	16:58
6	Pat LaFontaine P. LaFontaine	310	597	318	628	-9	345	90	122	5	0	37	4	1,799	17.2
7	Denis Potvin D. Potvin	310	1,060	742	1,052	+456	1,356	127	332	10	22	44	0	3,050	10.2
8	Clark Gillies C. Gillies	304	872	359	663	+244	891	92	104	0	0	41	0	2,124	14.3
9	Brent Sutter B. Sutter	287	694	323	610	+120	761	90	86	12	5	37	1	1,661	17.3
10	Brock Nelson B. Nelson	285	870	264	549	+5	306	61	55	4	2	43	8	2,005	14.2	4,595	9,624	47.7	599	513	463	430	16:53
11	Adam Graves A. Graves	280	772	227	507	+6	810	100	65	16	11	36	5	2,309	12.1	79	149	53.0	352	50	75	50	17:12
12	Anders Lee A. Lee	273	789	204	477	+22	479	76	46	0	0	41	1	1,979	13.8	364	769	47.3	1,337	403	238	292	16:19
13	John Tavares J. Tavares	272	669	349	621	-42	307	83	130	3	3	42	11	2,110	12.9	6,287	12,259	51.3	318	235	586	643	20:01
14	Andy Bathgate A. Bathgate	272	719	457	729	-28	444	59	162	6	3	23		1,384	9.7
15	Vic Hadfield V. Hadfield	262	841	310	572	+16	1,041	83	82	0	0	40		2,414	10.9
16	Camille Henry C. Henry	256	637	222	478	-46	72	116	94	0	0	32		746	21.2
17	Mark Messier M. Messier	250	698	441	691	+74	667	72	160	23	28	41	3	1,658	15.1	2,824	5,187	54.4	145	112	118	241	18:12
18	Steve Vickers S. Vickers	246	698	340	586	+57	330	69	99	1	1	35		1,278	19.2
19	Brian Leetch B. Leetch	240	1,129	741	981	+24	525	106	408	8	13	37	7	3,469	6.9	0	0		356	549	271	362	27:02
20	Bob Bourne B. Bourne	238	814	304	542	+162	542	38	52	16	12	37	1	1,573	15.1
21	Mika Zibanejad M. Zibanejad	236	595	312	548	+41	181	103	98	11	15	35	8	1,699	13.9	5,214	10,427	50.0	569	418	415	448	19:34
22	Bobby Nystrom B. Nystrom	235	900	278	513	+110	1,248	27	22	0	0	38	0	1,823	12.9
23	Bill Cook B. Cook	228	475	138	366		386	9	12	0	0	43	5
24	Walt Tkaczuk W. Tkaczuk	227	945	451	678	+184	556	41	73	11	18	23		2,156	10.5
25	Derek King D. King	211	638	288	499	+3	344	81	94	1	0	30	1	1,409	15.0