Al Smith has the most penalty minutes by a goalie in a game, with 32 minutes in the box versus the Hartford Whalers on November 6, 1980.

most penalty minutes in a regular-season game by both goalie

	NAME	PIM	DATE	TM		OPP	DEC	SA	SV	SV%	GA	GAA	SHO	MIN
1	Al Smith A. Smith	32	11/6/1980	CLR	vs	HFD		1	1	1.000	0	0.00	0	1
2	Patrick Roy P. Roy	31	4/1/1998	COL	@	DET	L	24	22	.917	2	2.27	0	53
3	Ray Emery R. Emery	29	11/1/2013	PHI	vs	WSH		15	11	.733	4	10.53	0	23
4	Ron Hextall R. Hextall	29	11/10/1996	PHI	vs	TOR	W	26	25	.962	1	1.00	0	60
5	Corey Schwab C. Schwab	29	12/9/1995	NJD	vs	NYI		11	11	1.000	0	0.00	0	27
6	Robert Esche R. Esche	27	3/5/2004	PHI	vs	OTT	W	22	20	.909	2	2.06	0	58
7	Dan Cloutier D. Cloutier	27	3/3/2000	TBL	@	CHI		11	10	.909	1	2.18	0	28
8	Bob Sauve B. Sauve	27	2/27/1986	CHI	@	LAK	W	20	17	.850	3	4.99	0	36
9	Mike Vernon M. Vernon	25	4/1/1988	CGY	vs	LAK	L	13	9	.692	4	6.61	0	36
10	Andy Moog A. Moog	24	2/8/1992	BOS	vs	NJD	L	21	16	.762	5	5.08	0	59
11	Don Beaupre D. Beaupre	24	1/5/1986	MNS	@	CHI	L	47	41	.872	6	6.41	0	56
12	Ryan Miller R. Miller	22	11/5/2016	VAN	@	TOR	L	42	36	.857	6	6.56	0	55
13	Ray Emery R. Emery	22	2/22/2007	OTT	@	BUF		15	12	.800	3	7.16	0	25
14	Glen Hanlon G. Hanlon	22	11/8/1981	VAN	vs	WIN	W	25	25	1.000	0	0.00	0	50
15	Richard Sevigny R. Sevigny	22	3/21/1981	MTL	vs	VAN		6	5	.833	1	6.43	0	9
16	Andy Brown A. Brown	22	3/30/1974	PIT	@	STL		18	15	.833	3	3.28	0	55
17	Gump Worsley G. Worsley	22	10/21/1972	MNS	vs	AFM		12	11	.917	1	2.20	0	27
18	Cameron Talbot C. Talbot	21	2/1/2020	CGY	vs	EDM		21	19	.905	2	7.38	0	16
19	Mark Laforest M. Laforest	21	10/23/1989	TOR	vs	NJD	L	20	15	.750	5	8.06	0	37
20	Phil Myre P. Myre	21	2/22/1980	PHI	@	VAN	W	34	31	.912	3	3.00	0	60
21	Patrick Roy P. Roy	20	3/30/2002	COL	@	PHX	L	20	16	.800	4	4.97	0	48
22	Tom Barrasso T. Barrasso	20	4/8/1994	PIT	@	NJD	L	22	16	.727	6	9.00	0	40
23	Tom Barrasso T. Barrasso	20	11/11/1991	PIT	@	NYR	L	25	23	.920	2	2.13	0	56
24	Frank Pietrangelo F. Pietrangelo	20	12/11/1990	PIT	vs	CHI	L	32	29	.906	3	3.54	0	51
25	Ron Hextall R. Hextall	20	1/10/1988	PHI	vs	NJD		5	3	.600	2	12.97	0	9