Between the 2009-10 and 2018-19 seasons, John Tavares recorded the most points for the Islanders, with 621 points.

	NAME	P	GP	G	A	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	John Tavares J. Tavares	621	669	272	349	-42	307	83	130	3	3	42	11	2,110	12.9	6,287	12,259	51.3	318	235	586	643	20:01
2	Josh Bailey J. Bailey	408	729	133	275	-30	203	27	74	5	3	18	6	1,187	11.2	1,118	2,517	44.4	425	342	477	476	16:37
3	Kyle Okposo K. Okposo	325	455	119	206	-57	272	25	67	0	1	18	5	1,166	10.2	441	912	48.4	378	211	317	290	18:41
4	Frans Nielsen F. Nielsen	311	516	107	204	+9	94	23	76	14	5	10	1	1,023	10.5	3,446	7,147	48.2	236	436	349	225	17:34
5	Anders Lee A. Lee	258	425	152	106	+11	256	48	26	0	0	22	0	1,053	14.4	96	204	47.1	758	187	134	143	15:46
6	Brock Nelson B. Nelson	241	480	124	117	+3	173	23	26	1	1	17	3	979	12.7	2,060	4,480	46.0	383	295	264	203	15:45
7	Matt Moulson M. Moulson	223	304	118	105	-10	56	44	32	0	0	13	1	846	13.9	11	21	52.4	258	177	183	95	18:23
8	Nick Leddy N. Leddy	191	402	40	151	-36	89	11	59	0	1	4	1	647	6.2	0	0		405	479	144	262	21:57
9	Casey Cizikas C. Cizikas	157	486	64	93	+10	194	1	4	6	5	12	0	577	11.1	2,985	5,966	50.0	932	369	268	151	12:57
10	Mathew Barzal M. Barzal	147	166	40	107	-6	82	8	37	0	0	7	2	349	11.5	602	1,427	42.2	47	87	131	205	17:45
11	Travis Hamonic T. Hamonic	146	444	26	120	-7	452	6	19	1	2	2	0	812	3.2	0	0		859	883	241	355	22:39
12	Michael Grabner M. Grabner	144	297	90	54	-7	50	5	4	11	1	11	3	710	12.7	22	50	44.0	184	121	272	137	14:43
13	Ryan Strome R. Strome	126	258	45	81	+5	123	8	19	1	0	5	0	514	8.8	500	1,132	44.2	257	69	127	144	15:14
14	Mark Streit M. Streit	123	212	24	99	-41	116	15	41	0	0	4	2	419	5.7	0	2	0.0	222	333	146	173	24:16
15	Johnny Boychuk J. Boychuk	120	340	33	87	+45	119	10	19	1	3	8	1	810	4.1	3	3	100.0	738	654	83	242	20:33
16	PA Parenteau	120	161	38	82	-16	135	15	24	0	0	4	1	328	11.6	21	56	37.5	217	51	82	110	18:26
17	Cal Clutterbuck C. Clutterbuck	119	441	55	64	0	257	3	2	8	4	14	1	687	8.0	39	90	43.3	1,558	197	140	143	13:15
18	Thomas Hickey T. Hickey	115	449	22	93	+35	190	0	4	0	4	6	5	494	4.5	1	2	50.0	486	689	143	300	18:07
19	Matt Martin M. Martin	102	505	48	54	-41	733	1	2	0	3	10	0	625	7.7	41	106	38.7	2,303	259	139	123	11:27
20	Jordan Eberle J. Eberle	96	159	44	52	-1	38	10	12	0	0	12	1	343	12.8	21	53	39.6	82	65	72	78	16:18
21	Andrew MacDonald A. MacDonald	89	292	17	72	-13	137	5	23	0	1	4	0	303	5.6	0	1	0.0	196	760	185	202	23:20
22	Anthony Beauvillier A. Beauvillier	88	218	48	40	+4	34	4	7	0	0	8	0	389	12.3	221	520	42.5	248	90	77	80	14:07
23	Calvin de Haan C. de Haan	81	304	12	69	+26	118	2	5	1	0	2	0	427	2.8	0	1	0.0	568	687	106	212	19:55
24	Blake Comeau B. Comeau	81	154	41	40	-30	89	5	10	2	3	5	1	335	12.2	47	141	33.3	267	67	103	89	16:48
25	Nikolay Kulemin N. Kulemin	79	248	37	42	+23	61	1	1	4	2	7	0	288	12.8	48	120	40.0	330	168	116	85	14:09