Tommy Soderstrom has the highest goals-against average by a goalie in a game, with a 360.00 average versus the Rangers on March 31, 1996.

NHL goalie highest gaa in a regular-season game

	NAME	GAA	DATE	TM		OPP	DEC	SA	SV	SV%	GA	SHO	MIN
1	Tommy Soderstrom T. Soderstrom	360.00	3/31/1996	NYI	vs	NYR		1	0	.000	1	0	0
2	Ken Lockett K. Lockett	200.00	3/6/1976	VAN	@	KCS		1	0	.000	1	0	0
3	Pheonix Copley P. Copley	184.62	1/21/2023	LAK	@	NSH		3	1	.333	2	0	1
4	Daniel Berthiaume D. Berthiaume	184.62	11/17/1993	OTT	vs	NYI		2	0	.000	2	0	1
5	Derek Wilkinson D. Wilkinson	133.33	11/14/1996	TBL	@	STL		1	0	.000	1	0	0
6	Alain Chevrier A. Chevrier	133.33	12/19/1986	NJD	vs	WSH		3	0	.000	3	0	1
7	Karel Vejmelka K. Vejmelka	122.03	11/6/2021	ARI	vs	SEA		2	0	.000	2	0	1
8	Rejean Lemelin R. Lemelin	109.09	3/29/1984	CGY	vs	LAK		1	0	.000	1	0	1
9	Jocelyn Thibault J. Thibault	107.46	11/13/1993	QUE	@	TBL		3	1	.333	2	0	1
10	John Vanbiesbrouck J. Vanbiesbrouck	105.88	2/9/1991	NYR	@	MTL	L	1	0	.000	1	0	1
11	Andrew Raycroft A. Raycroft	90.00	2/3/2011	DAL	@	BOS		2	0	.000	2	0	1
12	Niklas Backstrom N. Backstrom	90.00	3/29/2007	MIN	vs	CGY		2	0	.000	2	0	1
13	Greg Stefan G. Stefan	87.80	12/2/1987	DET	vs	EDM		1	0	.000	1	0	1
14	John Gibson J. Gibson	85.71	1/30/2021	ANA	vs	STL	L	6	3	.500	3	0	2
15	Denis Herron D. Herron	83.72	1/8/1975	PIT	@	CHI		1	0	.000	1	0	1
16	Darren Pang D. Pang	81.82	12/6/1988	CHI	@	PIT		2	0	.000	2	0	1
17	Don Beaupre D. Beaupre	80.00	1/2/1994	WSH	@	BOS	L	4	1	.250	3	0	2
18	Ron Hextall R. Hextall	78.26	3/4/1988	PHI	@	EDM		5	3	.600	2	0	2
19	Damian Rhodes D. Rhodes	77.70	1/5/2001	ATL	vs	PHI		3	0	.000	3	0	2
20	Kevin Poulin K. Poulin	75.79	2/20/2012	NYI	vs	OTT	L	5	3	.600	2	0	2
21	Johan Hedberg J. Hedberg	73.47	12/2/2010	NJD	vs	MTL	L	3	1	.333	2	0	2
22	Jim Carey J. Carey	72.73	1/5/1996	WSH	vs	NYR		3	1	.333	2	0	2
23	Michel Dion M. Dion	72.58	1/26/1982	PIT	@	NYI	L	6	1	.167	5	0	4
24	Cam Ward C. Ward	70.59	12/15/2010	CAR	@	FLA		5	3	.600	2	0	2
25	Scott Clemmensen S. Clemmensen	62.07	10/21/2009	FLA	vs	BUF		3	1	.333	2	0	2