Between the 2008-09 and 2022-23 seasons, the New York Islanders had the most penalties by a team in a game, with 34 penalties against the Penguins on February 11, 2011.

NHL team stats most penalties in a regular-season game between 2008-09 to 2022-23

	TEAM	PEN	DATE	TM		OPP	RESULT	G	GA	PPG	PPO	OPP PPG	OPP PPO	S	SA
1	Islanders	34	2/11/2011	NYI	vs	PIT	W 9-3	9	3	2	5	3	9	36	38
2	Penguins	31	2/11/2011	PIT	@	NYI	L 3-9	3	9	3	9	2	5	38	36
3	Bruins	25	2/9/2011	BOS	vs	MTL	W 8-6	8	6	1	3	4	8	34	33
4	Ducks	21	10/11/2010	ANA	@	STL	L 1-5	1	5	1	4	1	9	14	53
5	Blues	20	4/5/2014	STL	vs	COL	L 0-4	0	4	0	4	2	8	31	29
6	Canucks	20	1/18/2014	VAN	vs	CGY	W 3-2	2	2	1	3	1	4	33	33
7	Canadiens	20	2/9/2011	MTL	@	BOS	L 6-8	6	8	4	8	1	3	33	34
8	Senators	19	4/6/2023	OTT	@	FLA	L 2-7	2	7	0	6	3	6	58	30
9	Ducks	19	10/26/2014	ANA	vs	SJS	L 1-4	1	4	1	5	2	5	34	37
10	Flames	19	1/18/2014	CGY	@	VAN	L 2-3	2	2	1	4	1	3	33	33
11	Senators	19	3/23/2012	OTT	@	MTL	L 1-5	1	5	0	2	2	7	38	32
12	Islanders	19	10/13/2008	NYI	vs	BUF	L 1-7	1	7	0	6	3	11	24	35
13	Canucks	18	11/5/2016	VAN	@	TOR	L 3-6	3	6	0	4	1	5	29	42
14	Jets	18	11/14/2015	WPG	@	NSH	L 0-7	0	7	0	4	2	5	20	34
15	Sharks	18	10/26/2014	SJS	@	ANA	W 4-1	4	1	2	5	1	5	37	34
16	Flyers	18	11/1/2013	PHI	vs	WSH	L 0-7	0	7	0	5	2	7	30	32
17	Maple Leafs	18	1/8/2009	TOR	@	MTL	L 2-6	2	6	1	6	2	8	32	29
18	Bruins	18	11/1/2008	BOS	vs	DAL	W 5-1	5	1	1	6	0	6	25	36
19	Stars	18	11/1/2008	DAL	@	BOS	L 1-5	1	5	0	6	1	6	36	25
20	Panthers	17	4/6/2023	FLA	vs	OTT	W 7-2	7	2	3	6	0	6	30	58
21	Panthers	17	1/23/2018	FLA	@	DAL	L 1-6	1	6	1	6	2	6	34	39
22	Predators	17	11/14/2015	NSH	vs	WPG	W 7-0	7	0	2	5	0	4	34	20
23	Islanders	17	3/31/2011	NYI	vs	NYR	W 6-2	6	2	0	2	0	8	33	27
24	Ducks	17	10/26/2009	ANA	vs	TOR	L 3-6	3	6	1	3	5	10	28	39
25	Blue Jackets	17	3/26/2009	CBJ	vs	CGY	W 5-0	5	0	2	5	0	7	36	33