Since 1999-00, Chris Neil has the most penalty minutes, with 2,522 minutes in the box.

Interpreted as:

most penalty minutes by a player, since 2000

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Chris Neil C. Neil	2,522	1,026	112	138	250	-19	16	16	0	0	12	0	1,249	9.0	29	74	39.2	3,015	216	285	209	10:58
2	Zdeno Chara Z. Chara	1,952	1,596	207	464	671	+308	93	133	7	27	35	3	3,353	6.2	13	36	36.1	3,749	2,164	610	1,342	23:55
3	Scott Hartnell S. Hartnell	1,809	1,249	327	380	707	+66	109	79	4	4	54	5	2,777	11.8	191	484	39.5	1,848	501	441	572	15:38
4	Cody McLeod C. McLeod	1,630	776	72	55	127	-59	3	1	2	1	7	0	840	8.6	22	71	31.0	1,914	264	120	53	10:01
5	Steve Ott S. Ott	1,555	848	109	179	288	-66	28	28	4	9	16	2	1,115	9.8	3,129	5,705	54.8	2,399	281	241	322	14:35
6	Tom Wilson T. Wilson	1,540	845	184	222	406	+35	40	29	11	6	28	5	1,419	13.0	151	379	39.8	2,528	548	335	411	15:23
7	Jody Shelley J. Shelley	1,538	627	18	36	54	-35	1	2	0	0	2	0	391	4.6	8	34	23.5	859	95	45	71	6:09
8	Sean Avery S. Avery	1,533	580	90	157	247	+16	10	32	4	2	15	0	1,167	7.7	658	1,299	50.7	910	135	159	230	12:57
9	Corey Perry C. Perry	1,489	1,396	450	488	938	+59	125	164	6	4	78	6	3,466	13.0	112	348	32.2	1,288	503	511	715	16:35
10	Donald Brashear D. Brashear	1,488	696	57	89	146	-36	2	8	0	0	8	0	728	7.8	26	83	31.3	1,189	144	215	290	10:34
11	Eric Boulton E. Boulton	1,421	654	31	48	79	-38	1	0	0	0	2	0	452	6.9	9	31	29.0	692	122	87	103	6:44
12	Brenden Morrow B. Morrow	1,362	991	265	310	575	+107	84	68	8	5	47	3	1,670	15.9	158	408	38.7	2,426	433	393	707	16:48
13	Dion Phaneuf D. Phaneuf	1,345	1,048	137	357	494	-57	73	173	2	7	28	5	2,514	5.4	0	1	0.0	2,460	1,550	377	760	23:28
14	Ian Laperriere I. Laperriere	1,345	763	85	150	235	-15	3	0	2	10	12	1	813	10.5	2,125	4,310	49.3	1,312	526	396	244	14:08
15	Derek Dorsett D. Dorsett	1,314	515	51	76	127	-49	2	2	5	4	6	0	700	7.3	70	177	39.5	1,136	254	122	61	12:24
16	Wayne Simmonds W. Simmonds	1,313	1,037	263	263	526	-92	102	68	3	1	44	2	2,130	12.3	104	239	43.5	1,916	466	397	404	15:15
17	Milan Lucic M. Lucic	1,301	1,177	233	353	586	+59	48	68	0	0	36	1	1,798	13.0	290	634	45.7	3,275	344	393	646	15:00
18	Jared Boll J. Boll	1,298	579	28	38	66	-52	1	1	0	0	5	0	380	7.4	11	39	28.2	1,047	128	75	47	7:34
19	Matthew Barnaby M. Barnaby	1,280	499	64	106	170	+4	3	6	0	1	9	0	531	12.1	61	145	42.1	528	82	106	164	11:35
20	Daniel Carcillo D. Carcillo	1,233	429	48	52	100	-17	9	7	0	0	7	0	565	8.5	21	37	56.8	842	107	91	108	10:32
21	Evgeni Malkin E. Malkin	1,212	1,224	517	845	1,362	+35	184	329	4	1	86	14	3,834	13.5	6,038	13,463	44.8	719	525	1,032	1,187	19:32
22	Evander Kane E. Kane	1,200	941	326	295	621	-54	52	52	18	7	46	5	3,274	10.0	660	1,463	45.1	2,241	380	479	507	18:41
23	Colton Orr C. Orr	1,186	477	12	12	24	-33	0	0	0	0	4	0	173	6.9	7	25	28.0	732	115	42	40	6:04
24	Joe Thornton J. Thornton	1,184	1,578	411	1,080	1,491	+185	139	393	6	6	66	9	2,906	14.1	12,730	24,107	52.8	1,142	498	1,225	1,527	19:18
25	Matt Martin M. Martin	1,168	987	81	97	178	-40	2	3	0	3	13	0	1,067	7.6	91	231	39.4	3,936	458	224	229	10:45