Between the 1995-96 and 2005-06 seasons, Matthew Barnaby had the most penalty minutes, with 2,203 minutes in the box.

Interpreted as:

most penalty minutes by a player 1995-96 to 2005-06

	NAME	PIM	GP	G	A	P	+/-	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Matthew Barnaby M. Barnaby	2,203	735	108	176	284	+9	6	16	0	1	15	1	936	11.5	61	144	42.4	500	76	99	154	11:52
2	Tie Domi T. Domi	2,192	766	84	111	195	-33	9	5	0	0	8	0	755	11.1	21	64	32.8	508	48	57	149	10:05
3	Donald Brashear D. Brashear	2,068	735	72	101	173	-67	4	8	0	0	11	0	823	8.7	24	74	32.4	793	103	152	202	12:11
4	Rob Ray R. Ray	1,746	547	20	29	49	-11	1	0	0	0	3	0	198	10.1	2	4	50.0	236	15	11	43	4:52
5	Jeff Odgers J. Odgers	1,555	565	39	40	79	-48	2	1	0	0	6	0	432	9.0	4	13	30.8	264	43	13	58	7:38
6	Peter Worrell P. Worrell	1,554	391	19	27	46	-48	2	3	0	0	4	0	345	5.5	4	31	12.9	778	45	39	53	8:32
7	Paul Laus P. Laus	1,455	454	12	51	63	+10	0	4	1	2	0	0	327	3.7	0	1	0.0	275	48	57	36	10:51
8	Krzysztof Oliwa K. Oliwa	1,447	410	17	28	45	-17	1	1	0	0	5	0	273	6.2	4	12	33.3	192	15	32	47	5:24
9	Matt Johnson M. Johnson	1,421	459	22	20	42	-51	0	0	0	0	3	0	196	11.2	6	11	54.5	476	45	29	82	7:29
10	Denny Lambert D. Lambert	1,387	474	26	63	89	-26	3	2	0	0	2	0	406	6.4	10	31	32.3	266	39	55	53	9:16
11	Chris Simon C. Simon	1,385	595	125	128	253	+3	31	22	0	0	16	1	1,050	11.9	16	44	36.4	475	83	135	234	12:40
12	Bob Boughner B. Boughner	1,382	630	15	57	72	+27	1	3	0	4	4	0	388	3.9	1	2	50.0	810	353	42	165	16:26
13	Bryan McCabe B. McCabe	1,378	781	95	243	338	+36	44	116	4	9	17	4	1,427	6.7	1	6	16.7	1,013	625	74	459	24:52
14	Jason Wiemer J. Wiemer	1,376	690	89	108	197	-79	21	19	2	1	11	1	1,016	8.8	1,895	4,070	46.6	659	132	108	139	13:32
15	Todd Simpson T. Simpson	1,357	580	14	63	77	+13	0	0	0	2	2	0	477	2.9	0	3	0.0	420	232	107	193	15:54
16	Bryan Marchment B. Marchment	1,355	658	23	97	120	+50	1	13	1	5	3	1	638	3.6	1	2	50.0	765	336	86	226	17:29
17	Sean O'Donnell S. O'Donnell	1,333	756	23	126	149	+53	4	21	0	12	7	4	664	3.5	7	16	43.8	465	424	204	371	20:33
18	Andrei Nazarov A. Nazarov	1,315	544	50	66	116	-68	6	9	0	0	5	0	573	8.7	10	26	38.5	261	41	48	77	7:40
19	Ian Laperriere I. Laperriere	1,273	738	86	136	222	-55	4	5	4	10	16	1	803	10.7	1,655	3,268	50.6	854	284	239	173	14:35
20	Keith Tkachuk K. Tkachuk	1,271	665	352	325	677	+66	128	99	7	8	55	6	2,284	15.4	1,194	2,327	51.3	552	86	162	317	19:37
21	Sandy McCarthy S. McCarthy	1,260	620	62	68	130	-79	9	7	0	0	10	2	721	8.6	4	27	14.8	592	87	94	105	8:47
22	Craig Berube C. Berube	1,250	539	26	42	68	-36	2	1	0	0	3	0	356	7.3	29	70	41.4	242	23	26	53	6:32
23	Chris Gratton C. Gratton	1,243	797	171	269	440	-109	43	70	1	2	26	0	1,773	9.6	4,270	7,687	55.5	574	158	187	266	15:59
24	Jim Cummins J. Cummins	1,231	440	18	32	50	-37	0	1	0	0	4	0	270	6.7	14	42	33.3	184	37	20	35	7:07
25	Brad May B. May	1,210	590	78	100	178	-7	10	14	0	1	14	0	840	9.3	7	23	30.4	595	45	103	95	10:13