Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson tallied 14 penalties scored in Bundesliga and the Premier League in his career.

	NAME	PK	G	SEASON	CLUB	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	2	9	2010-11	Hoffenheim	29	1,247	10	0.31	3	12
2	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	0	7	2011-12	Total	25	2,076	24	0.28	4	11
3	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	0	3	2012-13	Tottenham	33	1,221	12	0.09	4	7
4	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	0	5	2013-14	Tottenham	25	1,301	14	0.20	0	5
5	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	0	7	2014-15	Swansea	32	2,697	32	0.22	10	17	2	67	24	3	1,758	0	2
6	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	3	11	2015-16	Swansea	36	2,917	32	0.31	3	14	2	88	32	3	1,818	0	4
7	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	3	9	2016-17	Swansea	38	3,327	37	0.24	13	22	2	116	50	3	1,906	99	1
8	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	0	4	2017-18	Everton	27	2,262	25	0.15	3	7	0	39	12	0	1,211	66	1
9	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	2	13	2018-19	Everton	38	3,134	36	0.34	6	19	0	86	34	3	1,720	106	3
10	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	1	2	2019-20	Everton	35	2,563	28	0.06	3	5	0	46	14	1	1,509	51	2
11	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	3	6	2020-21	Everton	36	2,254	24	0.17	5	11	0	49	17	2	1,279	50	0
	Total	14	76			354	24,999	274	0.21	54	130