Alan Shearer tallied the most penalties in the Premier League and when playing 5+ seasons, with 56 penalties scored.

most penalty goals by a player past five or more seasons premier league

	NAME	PK	SEAS	G	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Alan Shearer A. Shearer	56	14	260	441	38,197	427	0.59	64	324
2	Frank Lampard F. Lampard	43	20	177	609	48,871	546	0.29	102	279
3	Mohamed Salah M. Salah	35	11	189	310	25,463	286	0.61	89	278
4	Harry Kane H. Kane	33	11	213	320	26,953	302	0.67	47	260
5	Steven Gerrard S. Gerrard	31	17	121	504	41,129	466	0.24	89	210
6	Mark Noble M. Noble	28	16	47	414	32,029	373	0.11	36	83
7	Jamie Vardy J. Vardy	27	10	145	342	26,555	301	0.42	47	192	0	678	326	21	7,582	1,129	303
8	Sergio Agüero S. Agüero	27	10	184	275	19,869	235	0.67	47	231
9	Matt Le Tissier M. Le Tissier	25	10	100	270	20,692	234	0.37	64	164
10	Bruno Fernandes B. Fernandes	23	7	64	204	17,685	200	0.31	52	116	3	559	211	22	15,130	633	38
11	Wayne Rooney W. Rooney	23	16	208	491	38,027	421	0.42	100	308
12	Thierry Henry T. Henry	23	9	175	258	21,313	235	0.68	74	249
13	Luka Milivojević L. Milivojević	22	7	28	183	13,885	156	0.15	5	33	3	178	62	5	10,087	81	2
14	David Unsworth D. Unsworth	22	14	38	364	29,495	329	0.10	18	56
15	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	21	14	146	418	31,963	350	0.35	76	222
16	Leighton Baines L. Baines	20	15	32	420	35,421	397	0.08	53	85
17	Jorginho	19	7	21	196	13,601	156	0.11	8	29	0	78	32	1	13,736	72	0
18	Troy Deeney T. Deeney	18	6	47	165	12,880	141	0.28	21	68	0	283	118	2	6,144	482	78
19	Yakubu Aiyegbeni Y. Aiyegbeni	18	9	95	252	19,009	216	0.38	26	121
20	James Milner J. Milner	18	24	56	645	40,285	434	0.09	88	144
21	Ruud van Nistelrooy R. van Nistelrooy	18	5	95	150	12,181	137	0.63	14	109
22	Danny Murphy D. Murphy	18	15	50	417	30,328	336	0.12	55	105
23	Gareth Barry G. Barry	18	21	53	653	54,434	618	0.08	64	117
24	Gary McAllister G. McAllister	18	10	49	325	27,199	305	0.15	47	96
25	Peter Beardsley P. Beardsley	18	6	58	185	15,834	179	0.31	33	91