Jimmy Butler III posted his most points in a regular-season or postseason game in Game 4 of the 2023 First Round versus the Bucks, with 56 points.

	NAME	PTS	DATE	TM		OPP	MIN	REB	AST	STL	BLK	FGM	FGA	FG%	3PM	3PA	3P%	FTM	FTA	FT%	TS%	OREB	DREB	TOV	PF	+/-
1	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	56	4/24/2023	MIA	vs	MIL	41	9	2	0	1	19	28	67.9	3	8	37.5	15	18	83.3	78.0	4	5	1	0	+4
2	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	53	1/14/2016	CHI	@	PHI	49	10	6	3	0	15	30	50.0	2	4	50.0	21	25	84.0	64.6	4	6	4	4	+11
3	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	52	1/2/2017	CHI	vs	CHA	38	12	6	3	1	15	24	62.5	1	4	25.0	21	22	95.5	77.2	3	9	2	0	+15
4	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	47	5/27/2022	MIA	@	BOS	46	9	8	4	1	16	29	55.2	4	8	50.0	11	11	100.0	69.4	3	6	1	1	+8
5	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	45	4/19/2022	MIA	vs	ATL	39	5	5	2	0	15	25	60.0	4	7	57.1	11	12	91.7	74.3	0	5	0	0	+19
6	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	43	12/18/2015	CHI	vs	DET	56	8	2	2	2	14	29	48.3	1	4	25.0	14	16	87.5	59.7	1	7	3	5	-5
7	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	42	4/26/2023	MIA	@	MIL	46	8	4	2	1	17	33	51.5	3	10	30.0	5	9	55.6	56.8	1	7	5	2	-10
8	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	42	1/7/2017	CHI	vs	TOR	44	10	5	2	0	10	25	40.0	4	8	50.0	18	20	90.0	62.1	4	6	4	1	+8
9	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	42	1/3/2016	CHI	@	TOR	39	4	5	1	1	15	23	65.2	2	3	66.7	10	11	90.9	75.4	1	3	3	3	+11
10	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	41	5/17/2022	MIA	vs	BOS	41	9	5	4	3	12	19	63.2	0	2	0.0	17	18	94.4	76.2	5	4	2	3	+25
11	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	5/8/2022	MIA	@	PHI	42	3	6	2	2	13	20	65.0	2	6	33.3	12	13	92.3	77.8	0	3	1	1	-2
12	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	10/4/2020	MIA	vs	LAL	45	11	13	2	2	14	20	70.0	0	0		12	14	85.7	76.5	1	10	5	0	+20
13	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	8/31/2020	MIA	@	MIL	36	4	2	2	1	13	20	65.0	2	2	100.0	12	13	92.3	77.8	2	2	3	1	+7
14	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	1/25/2017	CHI	vs	ATL	40	4	3	3	0	13	22	59.1	4	8	50.0	10	10	100.0	75.8	2	2	1	0	-3
15	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	12/28/2016	CHI	vs	BKN	38	10	4	4	0	14	29	48.3	1	2	50.0	11	11	100.0	59.1	6	4	3	2	+4
16	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	40	11/20/2016	CHI	@	LAL	40	7	6	1	0	14	23	60.9	0	1	0.0	12	14	85.7	68.6	4	3	1	1	+14
17	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	39	12/27/2017	MIN	vs	DEN	42	4	5	1	0	10	20	50.0	3	6	50.0	16	18	88.9	69.8	0	4	1	0	+5
18	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	39	4/2/2017	CHI	@	NOP	39	6	5	1	1	14	26	53.8	3	3	100.0	8	10	80.0	64.1	3	3	1	0	0
19	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	39	11/9/2016	CHI	@	ATL	39	4	7	6	0	13	24	54.2	4	9	44.4	9	12	75.0	66.6	1	3	4	1	+8
20	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	3/11/2023	MIA	@	ORL	39	5	2	1	0	14	25	56.0	2	7	28.6	8	8	100.0	66.6	1	4	2	2	-8
21	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	2/3/2020	MIA	vs	PHI	29	7	2	3	0	14	20	70.0	2	2	100.0	8	8	100.0	80.8	2	5	0	2	+13
22	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	12/7/2018	PHI	@	DET	39	6	6	3	1	13	27	48.1	1	6	16.7	11	12	91.7	58.9	5	1	0	1	+12
23	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	12/5/2018	PHI	@	TOR	38	10	1	1	1	15	27	55.6	4	7	57.1	4	4	100.0	66.1	3	7	2	2	+3
24	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	2/9/2018	MIN	@	CHI	41	7	5	4	0	11	26	42.3	3	9	33.3	13	15	86.7	58.3	1	6	1	1	+6
25	Jimmy Butler III J. Butler III	38	12/12/2017	MIN	vs	PHI	46	6	3	1	0	15	33	45.5	3	9	33.3	5	5	100.0	54.0	3	3	1	1	-6