Auston Matthews has the most goals for the Maple Leafs in a season, with 69 scored in 2023-24.

	NAME	G	SEASON	TM	GP	A	P	+/-	PIM	PPG	PPA	SHG	SHA	GWG	OTG	S	S%	FOW	FO	FOW%	HIT	BKS	TKA	GVA	TOI/GP
1	Auston Matthews A. Matthews	69	2023-24	TOR	81	38	107	+31	20	18	11	0	1	8	3	369	18.7	705	1,319	53.4	89	93	85	54	20:58
2	Auston Matthews A. Matthews	60	2021-22	TOR	73	46	106	+20	18	16	13	0	0	10	2	348	17.2	691	1,229	56.2	67	62	92	48	20:37
3	Rick Vaive R. Vaive	54	1981-82	TOR	77	35	89	+12	157	12	6	5	1	6		267	20.2
4	Dave Andreychuk D. Andreychuk	53	1993-94	TOR	83	46	99	+22	98	21	23	5	0	8	0	333	15.9
5	Rick Vaive R. Vaive	52	1983-84	TOR	76	41	93	-11	114	17	14	0	0	6	0	261	19.9
6	Gary Leeman G. Leeman	51	1989-90	TOR	80	44	95	+4	63	14	12	1	0	5	0	256	19.9
7	Rick Vaive R. Vaive	51	1982-83	TOR	78	28	79	-13	105	18	12	3	1	8		296	17.2
8	Frank Mahovlich F. Mahovlich	48	1960-61	TOR	70	36	84	+23	131	7	13	0	0	10		223	21.5
9	Auston Matthews A. Matthews	47	2019-20	TOR	70	33	80	+19	8	12	13	0	0	5	0	290	16.2	506	920	55.0	40	60	78	48	20:58
10	John Tavares J. Tavares	47	2018-19	TOR	82	41	88	+19	34	10	9	0	0	8	1	286	16.4	832	1,528	54.5	59	53	53	72	19:05
11	Lanny McDonald L. McDonald	47	1977-78	TOR	74	40	87	+35	54	11	17	0	0	5		241	19.5
12	Wendel Clark W. Clark	46	1993-94	TOR	64	30	76	+10	115	21	11	0	0	8	2	275	16.7
13	Lanny McDonald L. McDonald	46	1976-77	TOR	80	44	90	+12	77	16	14	4	2	5		293	15.7
14	Darryl Sittler D. Sittler	45	1977-78	TOR	80	72	117	+34	100	14	22	0	0	8		311	14.5
15	Darryl Sittler D. Sittler	43	1980-81	TOR	80	53	96	-8	77	14	18	2	1	2		267	16.1
16	Lanny McDonald L. McDonald	43	1978-79	TOR	79	42	85	+11	32	16	13	0	0	2		314	13.7
17	Errol Thompson E. Thompson	43	1975-76	TOR	75	37	80	+28	26	13	7	1	1	7		210	20.5
18	Eddie Olczyk E. Olczyk	42	1987-88	TOR	80	33	75	-22	55	14	10	4	3	3	0	243	17.3
19	Auston Matthews A. Matthews	41	2020-21	TOR	52	25	66	+21	10	10	3	0	0	12	2	222	18.5	450	867	51.9	57	47	47	53	21:33
20	Mats Sundin M. Sundin	41	2001-02	TOR	82	39	80	+6	94	10	14	2	1	9	2	262	15.6	1,041	1,812	57.5	59	32	32	65	19:20
21	Mats Sundin M. Sundin	41	1996-97	TOR	82	53	94	+6	59	7	13	4	3	8	0	281	14.6
22	Darryl Sittler D. Sittler	41	1975-76	TOR	79	59	100	+12	90	11	12	1	2	2		346	11.8
23	William Nylander W. Nylander	40	2023-24	TOR	82	58	98	+1	24	11	24	3	1	7	2	316	12.7	56	119	47.1	32	29	68	45	19:55
24	Auston Matthews A. Matthews	40	2022-23	TOR	74	45	85	+31	20	13	15	0	0	8	0	327	12.2	550	1,049	52.4	78	92	68	55	20:17
25	William Nylander W. Nylander	40	2022-23	TOR	82	47	87	+10	28	9	19	0	0	5	3	293	13.7	25	59	42.4	18	26	70	37	18:33