Teddy Sheringham has tallied the most career goals by a 40-year-old player in the Premier League, with 2 goals.

Interpreted as:

most goals by a player over the age of 40

	NAME	G	AGE	DATE	CLUB		OPP	MIN	YC
1	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40	4/2/2006	West Ham	vs	Charlton	45	0
2	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-007	4/9/2006	West Ham	@	Chelsea	19	0
3	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-013	4/15/2006	West Ham	vs	Man City	8	0
4	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-015	4/17/2006	West Ham	@	Middlesbrough	90	1
5	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-024	4/26/2006	West Ham	vs	Liverpool	90	0
6	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-029	5/1/2006	West Ham	@	West Brom	67	0
7	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-035	5/7/2006	West Ham	vs	Tottenham	67	0
8	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-139	8/19/2006	West Ham	vs	Charlton	8	0
9	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-142	8/22/2006	West Ham	@	Watford	24	0
10	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-146	8/26/2006	West Ham	@	Liverpool	8	0
11	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-182	10/1/2006	West Ham	vs	Reading	18	1
12	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-195	10/14/2006	West Ham	@	Portsmouth	70	1
13	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	1	40-210	10/29/2006	West Ham	vs	Rovers	77	0
14	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-217	11/5/2006	West Ham	vs	Arsenal	27	0
15	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-223	11/11/2006	West Ham	@	Middlesbrough	90	0
16	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-230	11/18/2006	West Ham	@	Chelsea	9	0
17	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-237	11/25/2006	West Ham	vs	Sheffield Utd	23	0
18	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-245	12/3/2006	West Ham	@	Everton	21	0
19	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-248	12/6/2006	West Ham	vs	Wigan Athletic	33	0
20	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-251	12/9/2006	West Ham	@	Bolton	30	0
21	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-259	12/17/2006	West Ham	vs	Man United	31	1
22	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-265	12/23/2006	West Ham	@	Fulham	20	0
23	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	1	40-268	12/26/2006	West Ham	vs	Portsmouth	45	0
24	Teddy Sheringham T. Sheringham	0	40-272	12/30/2006	West Ham	vs	Man City	68	0
	Total	2						988	4