Between the 2009-10 and 2019-20 seasons, Sergio Agüero scored the most penalties in the Premier League, with 26 penalties scored.

most penalty goals by a player 2009-10 to 2019-20 in premier league

	NAME	PK	G	M	MIN	START	G/M	A	G+A	FK	SH	SOT	WOOD	TCH	TCH-BOX	OFF
1	Sergio Agüero S. Agüero	26	180	263	19,311	228	0.68	46	226
2	Mark Noble M. Noble	24	38	307	25,202	295	0.12	30	68
3	Frank Lampard F. Lampard	23	70	177	12,091	136	0.40	25	95
4	Wayne Rooney W. Rooney	23	128	267	21,364	240	0.48	54	182
5	Luka Milivojević L. Milivojević	21	27	119	10,242	115	0.23	4	31	3	144	55	5	7,548	69	2
6	Harry Kane H. Kane	20	143	210	17,227	193	0.68	21	164
7	Steven Gerrard S. Gerrard	20	50	171	14,288	158	0.29	34	84
8	Leighton Baines L. Baines	19	28	295	25,740	288	0.09	46	74
9	Troy Deeney T. Deeney	18	47	163	12,857	141	0.29	21	68	0	281	118	2	6,133	477	78
10	Jamie Vardy J. Vardy	18	103	211	17,218	196	0.49	28	131	0	455	221	15	5,270	643	192
11	Eden Hazard E. Hazard	17	85	245	19,470	222	0.35	51	136
12	James Milner J. Milner	17	40	333	21,752	234	0.12	58	98
13	Joshua King J. King	12	48	161	12,104	140	0.30	14	62	0	271	108	5	6,002	537	39
14	Carlos Tévez C. Tévez	12	58	113	8,415	97	0.51	24	82
15	Charlie Adam C. Adam	11	33	207	13,229	152	0.16	24	57
16	Yaya Touré Y. Touré	11	62	230	18,245	211	0.27	29	91
17	Glenn Murray G. Murray	10	37	148	7,548	82	0.25	5	42
18	Christian Benteke C. Benteke	10	72	225	16,287	178	0.32	21	93
19	Jon Walters J. Walters	10	43	229	16,705	189	0.19	19	62
20	Darren Bent D. Bent	10	56	143	10,532	114	0.39	5	61
21	Arteta	10	24	154	12,046	137	0.16	12	36
22	Robin van Persie R. van Persie	10	105	165	13,180	148	0.64	36	141
23	Gylfi Þór Sigurðsson G. Þór Sigurðsson	9	61	282	20,922	233	0.22	45	106
24	Riyad Mahrez R. Mahrez	8	57	199	14,215	163	0.29	39	96	3	426	185	10	10,127	489	45
25	Santi Cazorla S. Cazorla	8	25	129	10,810	122	0.19	32	57